Page 1 of 5
Math 481/581 Ethnomathematics: A multicultural view of mathematical ideas and methods.
Southern Oregon University Summer 1998 Dr. Richard G. Montgomery
M-T-W-Th 10-12:20 Four Week Session rmontgomery@sou.edu (541) 552-6580
Prerequisites. Upper-division standing and the following or their equivalent: Wr 122, Math 212, and Math 213; or Math 251 and Math 261. Math 581 has an additional prerequisite of senior standing or higher.
Content. This course will examine mathematical thought and practice of other cultures. Comparisons to the Western tradition will be made. The mathematics which underlies activities in other cultures will be investigated. We will consider how the mathematics found in other traditions reflects that culture's heritage and world view.
Mathematical topics include numbering and systems of organization; and geometry and perceptions of space. Other topics will be considered as they arise.
Activities and Requirements. There will be a variety of readings and resource investigations. There will be reports, both verbal and written, which share information. You will be expected: to contribute to the discussion of the common readings; to locate and share some ethnomathematics case studies; to join in the discussion which clarifies and integrates the examples presented by fellow students.
During class time there will be discussions, presentations, and an occasional 'scissors-activity'.
Outside of class time there will be critical readings, resource searches, and presentation preparations. Also, there will be the ongoing development of a course notebook.
Course Notebook. It is hoped that your notebook will be the beginning of a continuing collection of useful materials on ethnomathematics [Organize your notebook by categories: Readings with annotations and notes; Classroom notes with annotations; Overall observations and course summary; Appendices: Resources; Reports of other students.]
Grading. Your course grade will be based on four factors: (1) your participation in the class discussion of the required readings, (2) your contribution of new resources and instances (reports and projects), (3) your course notebook , and (4) your overall contribution to the success of the course.
Required texts. [All available in paperback.]
(A complete list of required and optional readings is appended.)
Marcia Ascher & Robert Ascher. Mathematics of the Incas. Dover Press. 1997.
Marcia Ascher, Ethnomathematics. Chapman and Hall. 1994.
Michael Closs, Native American Mathematics. The University of Texas Press. 1986.
Gary Urton. The Social Life of Numbers: A Quechua Ontology of Numbers and Philosophy of Arithmetic. The University of Texas Press. 1997.
Claudia Zaslavsky, Africa Counts. Lawrence Hill Books. 1991.
Optional. Join the International Study Group on Ethnomathematics (the ISGEm) at $15.00/ year.
ISGEm home page address: http://www.cohums.ohio-state.edu/comp/isgem.htm
Page 2 of 5
Math 481/581 Ethnomathematics: A multicultural view of mathematical ideas and methods.
Southern Oregon University Summer 1998 Dr. Richard G. Montgomery
Ethnomathematics.
What is ethnomathematics? The word 'ethnomathematics' is itself rather new on the scene; only about a decade old. In recent years there has emerged a large, growing, and very active, international advocacy of 'ethnomathematics'. Today almost every major math conference has associated meetings of teachers and/or scholars concerned with the multicultural aspects of mathematics. Simply enter the word 'ethnomathematics' in a SEARCH box on the internet and you will be overwhelmed with information.
But, what is ethnomathematics? The domain of ethnomathematics has several overlapping aspects. (1.) Some 'ethnomathematicians' search out instances of activities in other traditions which can be analyzed in terms of western mathematics. (2.) Others are truly 'anthro-mathematicians;' these are trained anthropologists who, in order to better understand a particular culture, examine the mathematics woven into and shaped by the fabric of that culture's heritage and activities. (3.) Yet others are sociologically oriented, primarily concerned with the plight of peoples of non-western tradition who are asked to learn 'western mathematics' (often in a very formal structured way).
In practice, these three approaches to ethnomathematics are mutually supporting and often intermingled.
This course will be devoted primarily to the first two aspects. Hopefully, the third aspect will benefit as a corollary to the first two. I believe that if we begin to get an inkling of how other traditions perceive the world, we'll naturally become more sensitive and responsive to the varieties of cultural backgrounds found in our own classrooms. Indeed, we teachers will be more able to take advantage of the 'diversity of thought' sitting before us in our classrooms but may not now even see.
For this summer's course I have chosen two main mathematical themes: 'numbering' and 'the perception of space' (there will be others too). There will be a mix of activities (e.g. making and understanding the complexity and use of an Inca quipu) and readings from brief case studies (such as the Sikidy system of divination practiced in Madagascar) to a comprehensive study of mathematical concepts of an enduring culture (the Quechua language group of South America. And, in order to better appreciate the meaning of "Seeing With a Native Eye" (à la folklorist Barre Toelken), we will not forget to examine our own highly organized, 'western way' of structuring in the world.
What is the purpose of holding an ethnomathematics course? Simple. To better understand mathematical concepts and be better teachers. We will better understand our 'subject matter' (our 'western' mathematical system of structures) if we see how basic mathematical ideas arise and are used elsewhere. Moreover, if we recognize that there are culturally different ways of 'seeing, organizing, and thinking,' then there is promise that we may ourselves devise ways to better teach mathematics.
Math 481/581 Ethnomathematics Southern Oregon University Summer 1998 page 3 of 5
Tentative Schedule & Miscellaneous Information
Colloquium Participants: Jim Earley, Fred Hamlin, Mark Schwarz, Teresa Woolley
Day
one Intro to Course: Format and Topic. Syllabus and Responsibilities.
two Case Study: Divination in Madagascar.
Readings: Ascher, "Introduction" from Ethnomathematics.
Ascher, "Malagasy Sikidy. . ." Discussion Leader: Jim Earley
three Cultural Worldviews: Navaho et.al.
Readings: Shirley, "Using Ethnomath to Find Multicultural Connections." Toelken, "Folklore and Cultural Worldview." Discussion Leader: Mark Schwarz
four Cultural Perceptions of 'Space.'
Readings: Ascher, "The Organization and Modeling of Space" Discussion Leader: Fred Hamlin
five Geometrical Perceptions From Around the World Discussion Leader: Teresa Woolley
Readings: Gerdes, "On Culture, Geometrical Thinking and Math Education."
Knijnik, "An Ethnomathematics Approach in Math Education:. . ."
six & seven The Inca Civilization
Readings: Ascher & Ascher, Math of the Incas.
Chapters 1, 2, 3, 4. Discussion Leader: Fred Hamlin Chapters 5, 6, 7. Discussion Leader: Mark Schwarz
eight & nine Number Systems From Around the World Discussion Leader: Teresa Woolley
Readings (1) & (2) provide universal overview. Reading (3) , however, is concerned with the cultural meaning of numbers in a specific language group, so the material requires a slower reading pace. Relax and enjoy.
(1) Zaslavsky, Africa Counts. Pages 2-11, 39-51. Read at a good pace.
(2) Closs, "Native American Number Systems." Read quickly for an overview:
page 3 - mid-p 7; bottom p 10 - bottom p 17; mid-p 24 - mid p 32; mid-p 41 - p 43.
(3) Urton, The Social Life of Numbers.
Page 39 - bottom 44. Top p 46 - 57. Page 66 - mid-68. Mid p 73 - mid-75.
ten, eleven, The Quechua.
TWELVE,
& Readings: Urton, The Social Life of Numbers: A Quechua...THIRTEEN
Chapter 4, 5, 1 Discussion Leader: Dick Montgomery Chapter 6 Discussion Leader: Jim Earley
fourteen & fifteen Individual Project Reports
sixteen & Seventeen Course summary & Conclusion. [Notebooks due.]
Page 4 of 5
Math 481/581 Ethnomathematics: A multicultural view of mathematical ideas and methods.
Southern Oregon University Summer 1998 Dr. Richard G. Montgomery
M-T-W-Th 10-12:20 Four Week Session rmontgomery@sou.edu (541) 552-6580
Literature and Resources
Basic Library of Books (R) Required
(R) Marcia Ascher & Robert Ascher. Mathematics of the Incas: Code of the Quipu. Dover Press. 1997.
(R) Marcia Ascher, Ethnomathematics: A Multicultural View of Mathematical Ideas. Brooks Cole. 1991.
(R) Michael Closs, Native American Mathematics. The University of Texas Press. 1986.
(R) Gary Urton. The Social Life of Numbers: Quechua Ontology of Numbers and Philosophy of Arithmetic. The University of Texas Press. 1997.
(R) Claudia Zaslavsky, Africa Counts. Lawrence Hill Books. 1991.
Other Books of Interest
Arthur Powell & Marilyn Frankenstein (ed.), Ethnomathematics. State University of New York Press. 1997. A collection of 18 articles from various sources.
Nelson, Joseph & Williams, Multiculltural Mathematics: Teaching Mathematics From a Global Perspective. Oxford University Press. 1993.
Articles
(R) Marcia Ascher, "Malagasy Sikidy: A Case Study in Ethnomathematics." Historia Mathematica 24, 376 - 395.
(R) Lawrence Shirley, "Using Ethnomathematics to Find Multicultural Mathematical Connections." 1995 NCTM Yearbook. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. 1995. 34 - 43.
(R) Barre Toelken, "Folklore and Cultural Worldview." Chapter 7 of The Dynamics of Folklore. Utah State University Press. 1996. Excerpt: 263 - 293.
(R) Paulus Gerdes, "On Culture, Geometrical Thinking and Mathematical Education." Educational Studies in Education. Dordrecht 19(3). 1988. 137- 162.
(R) Gelsa Knijnik, "An Ethnomathematical Approach in Mathematical Education: A Matter of Political Power." For the Learning of Mathematics. 13(3). 1992. 23 - 26.
(R) Eduardo Ferreira, "The concept of fraction among the Krahó Indians in Brazil." Mathematics Teaching. 162 (March ) 1998. ( Journal of the Association of Teachers of Mathematics). 29 - 30.
Other Information Sources
The articles by Ascher and by Lawrence have excellent lists of references. The reference lists found in Ascher, Ethnomathematics are well-annotated with substantial information.
The International Study Group on Ethnomathematics. Publishes the ISGEm Newsletter.
ISGEm Home Page http://www.cohums.ohio-state.edu/comp/isgem.htm
Other Works Cited or Mentioned in Class
Barre Toelken, "Seeing With a Native Eye: How Many Sheep Will It Hold?" in Capps (editor), Seeing with a Native Eye. Harper Forum Books.1976.
Math 481/581 Ethnomathematics Page 5 of 5
Literature and Resources [Continued]
O.R. Hardison, Jr. Disappearing Through the Skylight. Penguin Books. 1990. [Western civilization's linearization of its world is dramatized.]
Amin Sweeney, Reputations Live On. University of California Press. 1980. [This autobiography of Malaysian Mohamed Salleh bin Perang illustrates the imposition of European linear mathematics (triangulation or 'surveying the landscape') on other cultures during the colonization period.]
Henry Petroski, "The Petronas Twin Towers." American Scientist 84 (number 4) July-Aug 1996. 322 - 326. [Technology transfer with residue engineering benefits to local expertise.]
Historical Atlas of the United States, Centennial Edition. National Geographic Society. 1988. Pages 98-99. [Graphic evidence of the linearization of the world by western society. Look at those grid lines; forget the natural topography.]
Von del Chamberlain, When Stars Came Down to Earth: Cosmology of the Skidi Pawnee Indians of North America. Ballena Press. 1982. (Speculative at times.)
Stewart Culin, Games of the North American Indians. Vol 1 & 2. The University of Nebraska Press. 1992. (A magnificent, comprehensive study. Suggests that while there were many serious 'games,' few, if any, were games of strategy.)
"The Incas". The PBS Odyssey series. PBS Video. 1980. 58 minutes. ODS105 ISBN 55951-276-8.
References on the Quechua Speaking Peoples
Gary Urton, At the Crossroads of the Earth and the Sky : An Andean Cosmology .The University of Texas Press. 1981.
Billie Jean Isbell, To Defend Ourselves: Ecology and Ritual in an Andean Village. Waveland Press Inc. 1985. (Gives a detailed description of the traditional practices of reciprocity in everyday Andean life. These are the practices which Gary Urton feels are major formative factors in the Quachua sense of subtraction and symmetry.)
Counting
Georges Ifrah, From One To Zero: A Universal History of Numbers. Viking-Penguin Inc. 1985.
Karl Menninger, Number Words and Number Symbols: A Cultural History of Numbers. Dover Press. 1992. This one is often cited as a good source of information about numbers systems used throughout the world.
Journals which carry articles of ethnomathematical interest
For the Learning of Mathematics . A Canadian journal which has published a number of articles on ethnomathematics, mostly in the socio-pedagogical vein. This journal in indexed in ERIC (see below).
The Humanistic Network Journal . Harvey Mudd College. Claremont, CA 91711. A world network of mathematicians, humanitarians, and teachers of all levels, united by the goal of encouraging a more humanistic understanding of mathematics.
Mathematics Teaching. An excellent British journal devoted to the concerns of teaching .